Bad contractor SEO is checkable. You do not need to understand rankings to audit your own agency, because every failure mode below leaves evidence you can find in an afternoon, and each one maps to a position we publish on our About page, so you can also check whether we behave the way this article says an agency should.
Sign one: you would lose the work if you left
Ask one question: if we part ways, what do I keep? If the site lives on the agency’s proprietary platform, the content is licensed rather than owned, or the rankings are attached to pages on a domain that is not yours, you are renting your own visibility. The work should be yours: site, content, profiles, and hosting. An agency that builds equity it keeps has a retention strategy, not a service.
Sign two: you were guaranteed rankings
Local results vary by searcher, location, and day, and no agency controls them. A guaranteed position or a guaranteed number of leads is either a promise about something the promiser cannot control, or a promise about a search term chosen because nobody competes for it. Ask which specific searches the guarantee covers and how many people in your county run them. The commitment worth paying for is to the work, the sequence, and the reporting.
Sign three: your listings disagree with each other
Search your company name plus your city and read your own listings. An old address still alive in a directory, a tracking number that differs from the number on your site, two spellings of the business name: each conflict splits your identity in the systems deciding whether to show you, and it is among the most common problems we find in contractor audits. If your agency has been billing monthly and your listings conflict, the foundation was skipped.
Sign four: nobody verified the content
Open your newest page and check three things: are the claims dated, are the figures sourced, and would you personally sign your name to every sentence. Contractor sites accumulate unverified content fast, because volume is easy to invoice, and a page that states last year’s prices or another county’s code requirements as current fact damages trust with every reader who catches it. Content on your site is your company speaking. Someone should be checking what it says.
Sign five: the reports count activity, not calls
A report listing tasks completed, posts published, and impressions served is a report about the agency’s effort. The report that matters counts what you agreed to move: calls, form submissions, direction requests, against the one metric named at the start of the engagement. If no metric was named at the start, that is the finding. Effort is the invoice’s justification. The metric is the work’s.
What to do with a failing score
One sign is a conversation with your agency. Three or more is a pattern, and the pattern is worth a second opinion. The audit is how we give one: five scores, the specific pages and listings holding you back, and the first fix we would make, in writing, whether or not you hire us. If the honest finding is that your current agency is doing the work properly, the audit will say that too. If your business is a roofing company, the roofing-specific version of this program is where to read next.