One site, with a real page per location, is the right default for a multi-location brand: every review, link, and mention feeds a single domain’s authority, and every location inherits it. Separate sites per location split that authority into fragments that each start from zero, and they earn their keep only in specific situations: genuinely distinct brands, franchise ownership boundaries with real operational independence, or a location whose market identity is worth more than the shared domain. The decision test is below, from the multi-location program.
Why is one site the default?
Because authority is the scarcest asset you have, and a single domain compounds it. Every location’s reviews corroborate one entity; every earned link strengthens every branch’s pages; every article the brand publishes lifts the whole estate. Ten microsites divide that same effort by ten, and the division is worse than arithmetic: each fragment competes separately against rivals who concentrated, and each needs its own maintenance, security, and citation hygiene. Most multi-site estates we audit are not a strategy; they are an accumulation of decisions nobody owned, and the fix usually consolidates.
What makes a location page real enough to rank?
Local evidence a clone cannot fake: the branch’s own photos, staff, hours, and service nuances; directions from landmarks people actually use; the reviews that name that location; schema for that address. The one-site default only works when the location pages are built this way, because a single domain full of swapped-city templates is just a doorway farm with better hosting, and the estate post covers why ranking systems and customers both read it that way. One honest page per location, plus city coverage only where you genuinely operate, is the whole architecture.
When do separate sites earn their keep?
Three cases survive scrutiny. Distinct brands: if the locations trade under different names with different offers, forcing them onto one domain confuses the entity story more than it concentrates authority. Franchise boundaries: a franchisee who owns their marketing, their budget, and their local reputation sometimes needs assets corporate cannot touch, which is a governance reality before it is an SEO one; our franchise work has run exactly that play inside brand guidelines. And acquired equity: a bought location whose local name has decades of recognition and links can be worth keeping as its own property, bridged carefully rather than absorbed overnight. Outside those three, “every location wanted its own website” is how estates end up with ten weak sites instead of one strong one.
How do you consolidate without losing what you built?
Slowly and with a ledger. Inventory every microsite’s pages, rankings, and referring domains first, so you know what equity exists. Build the destination location pages before anything moves. Redirect page to page, old location homepage to new location page, never everything to the brand homepage, because a blanket redirect burns the specificity that made the equity. Update the citations and profiles to the new URLs in the same pass. Expect a rankings wobble measured in weeks, and measure it rather than panicking at it. The estates that regret consolidation are almost always the ones that did it as a redirect dump instead of a migration.
Start with the estate audit. It inventories every domain you own, what each is worth, and the consolidation or independence call per location, in writing, whether or not you hire us.